The Year I Was the Other Woman To Myself novel Chapter 217

They checked several branches of Sugar Bliss, but at this hour, they were all closed.

Penelope sighed heavily. "It's okay. I can live without it."

Her voice was thick with disappointment. She turned her head and wiped away a tear.

Theodore, amused, pulled out his phone and dialed the number on the storefront. "I know you're closed, but would it be possible for you to make something for us? Money is no object."

A few moments later, the shop door opened, and a server warmly welcomed them inside.

"The pastry chef is already getting started in the back. It won't be long."

Penelope still wasn't completely satisfied. "It would be perfect if it were raining right now."

Theodore sighed. "You have to understand, there are some things even your husband can't do."

Penelope immediately turned on the charm. "My husband is the best! The most amazing!"

The wait should have felt long, but for some reason, it flew by. Before she had even had a chance to sort through her emotions, a blueberry cake was placed in front of her.

She didn't want to eat it in the shop, insisting instead that Theodore take her to a deserted public square.

The staff, assuming it was someone's birthday, had included a paper crown and candles.

Penelope was about to toss them aside, but Theodore gently placed the crown on her head and arranged the candles on the cake, lighting them one by one.

"Happy birthday to you, happy birthday to you…"

He sang as he clapped, his eyes, full of laughter, shining like stars in the night sky.

Penelope smiled back, a warmth spreading through a cold, dark corner of her heart.

After the song, he told her to make a wish.

"It's not my birthday," she said.

"I know. But does that matter? If you want, I can celebrate your birthday with you every day."

VERIFYCAPTCHA_LABELVerify